When Things Go Wrong in the Court of Appeal: Harsher Criticism Reserved for Shortcomings of Home Office Presenting officers

 

RoyalCourtsofJusticeimage

“I  am yet to take  instructions  on  the point, Sir”

 

This should hopefully   never be  heard  uttered again  in the Tribunal by Home Office   Presenting Officers  upon a Judge making enquiry  about  relevant changes in the law or current  Home Office policy.  I say this  following the Court of Appeal’s  judgement in Koori & Ors v The Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] EWCA Civ 552.  The Court’s  view in effect  was  that although both Appellants and the Secretary of  State  should attend appeal  hearings fully prepared in terms of  the law, however,  in particular where  matters of statutory changes are concerned, the  greater responsibility lies upon the  Home Office  Presenting Officers.  This surely is correct and it is surprising that  it has taken so long for this to be stated in a judgement.

Continue reading